So when I first heard about Smashbox's new Halo Hydrating Perfecting Shadow Duo I was all, This is the coolest thing ever! I want them all. Because I love Smashbox shadows and how great is the idea that you twist the compact to shave just enough of the two shades to make you happy? So great. I totally want to be the person who invented that. But sadly, the execution leaves a little to be desired. The shadows are great - the colors complement each other well and they go on smoothly with a good amount of pigment and last for hours. The problem is the shaving mechanism. Both shadows get shaved at the same time, which means that the outer ring of the lighter color has a ton more shadow to apply than the middle shade, which is more of a contour color. If it was a small difference, that would be okay, but it's really not. I end up wasting a ton of the lighter color and having to spill it out just to get enough of the darker color to use. (And regardless of the fact that I have way, way, WAY too much makeup, I still don't want to purposefully have to waste any, you know? That goes against like, the rules of Product Whoredom). If I worked for Smashbox, I would redesign the compacts so that each color got shaved on its own. That way you could decide exactly how much of each shade you wanted and there would be no waste. (Especially because at $36, these definitely aren't the cheapest shadows you'll own). I'll definitely keep using the ones that I own though because I really do like the shadows themselves. (Especially the Pewter/Smoke and Petal/Plum combos. So pretty!)
You can test them out for yourself at Sephora.com or Smashbox.com.
Note: A sample of this product was sent to me by a PR representative working with Smashbox.





Recent Comments